Market Hope or Truth?
More specifically, should we market for hope or nothing but the truth involving ASL for parents of a Deaf child? Should we lead on the parents down the yellow brick road like many non-ASL proponents tend to do?
Marketing ASL to parents are constantly changing especially through more available Internet access that provides for more convenient and exploratory access of pertaining information for their Deaf child upon discovery in their family.
Recent vlogs from Eyepoetically ("Perspective of AG Bell exhibits...") and Deaf Chipmunk ("DBC: Resources and Opportunities!!!!") shared current marketing tactics at the recent AGB conference in Milwaukee and the urgent need to set up a center of resources to provide for the parents on bilingual or I'd like to say, dual language education, that incorporate ASL and English for a healthy life development for a Deaf child and family members.
Eyepoetically portrayed booths at the AGB conference in their vlog that market various methods, products, and of course, hope for the parent's Deaf child. Typical and potentially misleading catch phrases are often promoted like "Your child can talk!" or "Your child can hear!" may be appealing to the vulnerable parents who may want such outcomes for their profoundly-deaf child to come to fruition. However, when it concerns ASL, the propoents tend to market the science of early language development in a more realistic approach. "Your child can sign!" may not be appealing to new parents who have no concept of ASL or Deaf culture to begin with. This is something that needs exploring in terms of promoting ASL more effectively.
Earlier this year, "Deaf World As Eye See It" vlogged about the importance of marketing ASL to the mass audience (“Time is of the Essence! Market ASL Now!”) and marketing ASL through media format such as TV commercials after being inspired by a successful showing of the Pepsi Super bowl Ad that involved a Deaf culture joke and ASL ("Commercials in American Sign Language").
At the first DeafRead Conference last February, several presenters talked about marketing v/blogs through search engines and benefits of web documentations of Deaf v/blogs now available for the masses in cyberspace. Jared Evans talked about “Leveraging your v/blog: Build your online reputation and become a search engine darling!” and Dr. Charles Katz declared that "ASL is written!" in the form of the increasing archives of Deaf/HoH vlogs and blogs available in the grid.
So today, I want to talk about if we market hope or for truth? For the most, I'd say ASL proponents tend to market the truth. But, isn't it time to incorporate hope too? Can we go both ways? For example, Deaf babies with cochlear implants can improve speech development through inclusion of ASL. Also, ASL can provide early language acquisition and development for babies. The truth cannot be denied after realizing origins of hope in this modern era that are found to be actually effective.
In the Eyepoetically vlog, commenter Dianrez suggested, "If we marketed ASL like they do their instruments of hope, perhaps more people would believe in it and for much better reasons." From this perspective, we have to ask ourselves, "Are we really that desperate to resort to deceptive measures or should we promote ASL even better?"
Setting up a ASL center of resources at a blog is a feat in itself. Numerous literature must be screened and selected to provide impact of clarity for the parents regarding the benefits of ASL. Simplistic titles and keywords should be listed in v/blogs in order for the search engines to pick them up after basic random word searches. Links and backups may constantly need to be updated.
Several things here I'd like to explore for ASL promotions:
1) Journals
Some parents want to read scientific journals with hard data involving studies with results of high probabilities that suggest such findings are probably true. There are many journals out there and we need more relevant studies that benefit the promotion of ASL into one place. As a graduate student in Counseling, I often vlogged about good and bad journals that I come across in my classes and we need more people to talk about literature and science that recognize the importance of inclusion of ASL in a Deaf child and even adults.
2) Stories
Some parents want to read or listen to real people, to see or hear from themselves how they grew up Deaf or raised a Deaf child. With selected stories and videos, parents can see a Deaf child who is signing creatively and excitably because the child has access to language. For a Deaf child to be empowered to express self effectively is a pure joy. Parents of Deaf children can produce videos and show their interactions with the child and how they communicate with each other and the non-verbal cues involved. A smiling child in the videos can warm many hearts and it is of importance for parents to understand that a Deaf child can obtain a thriving personality once has access to languages set up by ASL! They can see that early development of reciprocity between the parent and child is very important. Seeing is believing.
3) Magic
Some parents want "magical outcomes" for their Deaf child. Strong emphasis on "ASL baby signs" encourages signing early can let their child have a head start in language acquisition and development. For an infant to let the parents know if they are "hungry," "wet," "tired," or want "milk," that is magical in itself!!! There is nothing deceptive about this and science are currently available.
4) Entertainment
Some parents may stumble into entertaining videos by Deaf people, for example, at youtube. Storytelling, poems, jokes, skits, movies, and even song interpretations may lead interest in learning ASL. I cannot tell you how many times ASL students or teachers or youtube subscribers contacted me to use my song signing videos for their classes or learn more about myself and my language. Several people told me that they were inspired to learn ASL apart from other methods they partaked into. You just never know! We all can contribute in our own ways to promote ASL and make it more appealing to many people in cyberspace.
5) Equal communication access
For the promotion of essential educational videos or vlogs, new parents often do not understand signing completely so sound and captions are recommended to be included in the videos. Taking advantage of available personnel or resources in the Internet can provide v/bloggers this type of accommodations. Transcripts are often the preferred mode of providing alternate access to the content of the signed vlogs and are found to be extremely helpful for search engines.
6) Mental Health
Set up listings of local and statewide agencies and services for further assistance for parents whether it will be with education, coping strategies, or family counseling for the Deaf child are needed. Such listings should encourage parents meeting Deaf counselors or those who are familiar with ASL and Deaf culture. Most importantly, promote the fact that inclusion of ASL within a Deaf child and in an environment leads to healthy life development. We should strive for more inclusion of qualified ASL personnel in infant medical wards that can act as early intervenors rather than unqualified medical personnel that often gives out discriminatory non-verbal cues to new parents that often leads to hysteria or misjudgment of choices. Make your local, state, and federal governments accountable by conveniently indulging into special interest groups that promote auditory-speech industries and for them to make an effort to seek fair inclusion of ASL parties in modern systems for the parents.
As you can see, there is nothing deceptive here in marketing ASL. We just have to be more creative. Information on ASL has been abundant and has been available all along. How to make the truth more appealing when it comes to ASL is an ongoing challenge toward a population that has no comprehension of the Deaf experience. Resorting to attacks or deception shows no class and honesty at all and we're better people without such tactics in the long run.



20 comments:
Mike!!!!!!
EXCELLENT BLOG! Finally, I'm so thrilled that you brought this important issue up!
We need to expend our energies to this avenue - because time is of essence, and we need to market American Sign Language NOW!
Every pro-ASL organizations and companies need to follow your suggestions.
I kiss-fist you!
Amy Cohen Efron
Mike,
I totally have to agree with you when gotta be creative and as you quoted "Resorting to attacks or deception shows no class and honesty at all and we're better people without such tactics in the long run" which I want to see happening cause we can't go backwards but go forward to make it the best of it. Just what Amy have been trying to say all along about marketing ASL and it's time to focus this than facts.
Thanks Mike
Blessings, Susan
Marvelous post! Marketing ASL for the reasons you have listed, especially mental health, has never been so clearly expressed.
People need to know this! It is not propaganda or false hope, nor even a maybe or "can help" like most of AGBell's sponsors use, but a factual reality: the acceptance by parents of their deaf children and caring enough to use a visual language is vital. The success of our endeavor hinges on bringing this information to the first people deaf children know.
That's why I proposed for the legal protection of our precious language, American Sign Language as part of "minority language" or "community language" in our country from my previous blog last two years ago.
We also could formally declare ourselves within the national government to appreciate the diversity of "family of language" and see us as true "cultural and linguistic minority" than letting the medical and educational community to define us as "disabled".
Most important of all is to get the legal definition of ASL as a true language, then ask for corporations, governments, community-minded organizations and individuals.
We could do the legal lawsuits against the AGBell and other audistic organizations and individuals for their past actions toward deaf individuals and left them in "legacy of shames and failures" than turning them into successful and meaningful citizens.
Yes, we have to do thru the legal means to make ourselves being taken seriously like the "Civil Rights Act of 1964" forced the American society to take up the issue of racism and prejudices.
Laws could transform the society more permanent than private incentives. Look at past African American enterpreuters from 1860s to 1960s! Those African American enterpreuters made millions and millions of dollars and couldn't change the societal attitudes toward racism and given prejudices, etc.
The legal recognizance of ASL as "minority language" FIRST, then market our beloved language to parents of deaf babies and youngsters to pave real success for deaf children to acquire language and social/emotional development without any struggles or frustrations.
Robert L. Mason (RLM)
I overlooked when I composed my comment.
I meant "ask for corporations, ...." to fund our outreach campaigns to reach the parents of deaf children..
RLM
Mike!
My heart melted!
Excellent, excellent, excellent post!
It's a great rich informative movement to promote ASL everywhere.
Deb Ann
Mike...
That's so perfect! I love it! Great marketing innovation! That would set more positive energy toward hearing parents of deaf babies.
Let's forget AGBell, everyone! Let's work on this kind of marketing we want to aim at the public. We don't need to waste our time and energies to fight AGBell. Let's focus on deaf babies and their hearing parents!
Beautiful blog, Mike!
Misha :D
Hey there! I don't often see you blog. I'm used to seeing you make vlogs. How coll it was to see what a great conceptual writer you are! Your ideas are well founded and you appear to have put great effort into this post. Good job, my friend.
I love the optimism you are focusing on lately. It's inspiring! Bring back the light, dear one. You are leading the way.
~ LaRonda
great blog, mike!! (i missed watching ur vlogs!! LoL)thumbs up!! Let's get busy! :)
Love this blog! We have been thinking exactly the same thing you are thinking. Market ASL making it look attractive and something to enrich parents' experience with their Deaf - Hoh kids.
I am thinking of a professionally made video of a child chatting with his/her friends then go about to sign with other kids and adults at a family-holiday-birthday party gathering scenario. Then a film shifts to a different scenario where a child also chat in only spoken language and watches signers signing, a subtitle appears (as if it is in his thought), "Only if I know sign..I do not fully fit in hearing world" something like this then the film returns to the first child with this more healthy outlook.
Maybe it seems too much. It is a thought how we market the concept of being bilingual and have the best of everything.
AnneMarie,
Your film idea is a good one... GO WITH IT!
Mike,
Yes, we do need to market ASL. I think we have already made a start with our vlogging. There are a lot of people in the deaf blogosphere who are quite bilingual. Some choose to blog only, or vlog only. We need to do both. This very act is one way to market ASL.
We do not have to "sell hope". All we have to do is "sell the truth" because in doing so, we are also selling hope. There is a difference btween the truth and propaganda.
Videotaping fluently bilingual adults who share their experiences of growing up bilingual would be excellent.
Videotaping a Deaf family with Deaf parents and children that are excellent models.
That's a start. These video packages could be part of the EHDI process... to balance out the pathological perspective.
Great entry Mike!! With the ideas you and others being thrown around, it will help with our data collection. With more "ASL Publication" coming our way, it will definitely grow with data. With all of testimonials, data, movie documentaries, and others, our case will become stronger than ever!
Nice blog. I agree with many of commenters above.
Anne Marie Baer, I hope you are not thinking about using your sons. Use someone else's children. Getting permission is not hard. You need a form and you can just get parents' signatures.
How about an aggressive campaign such as that of the one Sonic used (see this topic elsewhere by Amy)? The campaign used by Sonic seems like it was regional; perhaps a regional manager who knew something about deafness or had/knew a deaf child and pushed for it....what if we could get other national chains to do the same.... can we dream on national) scale?
DT
Thanks for the comments all, my eyes melted after writing this lengthy blog. Best I go back to vlogging, haha.
I see a lot of good comments and ideas here. We can make a difference in our own ways to get our messages across. Getting ASL recognized as a national language will help us a lot. Born in the U.S.A.
My parents are coming to town, it's time for company. Later.
Anonymous, I can understand why people think it is better if we try to use other kids than our own. I live in Boulder, most deaf babies and kids are about 45 minutes away from here. Parents really have to try to videotape a lot to try to capture their babies and kids' language production.
It is easier for us to do with our son Noam at our house where we are at the most of time. We keep our camera plugged on and seek for good chances of capturing child's language that comes out randomly.
If you happen to have a deaf toddler and can really watch him/her closely, sure, let us know and we will be glad to edit video clips and show about your kid's language development at work.
Hi Mike,
Just got back from cottage. I think I am getting more tan than yours!
Yes we need to provide parents more opportunities than options. Options appear more limited choices. Opportunities appear positive and healthy way of life. So we should provide parents the concept of opportunities rather than restricted options. We all love opportunities and Deaf children need that more than ever. Yet, I still believe we should not keep our eyes away from AGBell. It is never to be trusted at any cost. It is irresponsibility to let AGBell to do whatever it wants based on its rights. I think it is a crime. No question about that. I think we should do both ways by providing parents opporuunities and show the world who AGBell is.
Deafchip
Brilliantly written. I look forward to your future endeavors with your counseling degree! You def have the "big picture" thinking. I enjoy your vlogs as much as your blogs!
Parents need both HOPE and TRUTH!
Julie Rems-Smario
anne marie, I recall seeing your interaction videos and commenting positively about it via emails at that time. Quite fascinating to watch.
david, more tan than me? ;) Opportunities than options, interesting. Free choices.
precious, that means a lot coming from you. Soon I'll return to school and my 2nd year internship so I'm kinda freaked out now! Gonna be tougher than the last time. Anyway, sure, parents can have both, hope and truth. Lean on the realistic side if possible!
Anne Marie Baer, I understand it is convenient for you to videotape your sons. It is ok if you are using the clips for your personal website, but for your ASL Think Tank? It does not look professional at all. It seems so biased. A mother videotaping her own children to show proof of language development? I have seen some clips done by hearing mothers of their Deaf children speaking some words vocally. Very biased!
Thank you for taking consideration of people's feedback. I have seen some other people say that your ATT is like "a mommy website", not my words, but I can't help agreeing with the person.
Post a Comment