Netflix Subscribers: Call for Captions!
Hey Everyone,
You may have seen the news recently that Netflix was releasing a $99 set-top box that allows subscribers, at no extra charge, to view on-demand movies on their televisions. However, if you are a Netflix user and interested in watching streaming video on your computer or television you may be dismayed to find that there is no captioning or subtitles available for this service.
As the industry turns towards a more digital-streaming-media approach, we need to speak up and let the industry know that closed captioning and subtitles are important to us, our friends, and family.
Tell Netflix How You Feel
If captions are important to you, make your opinion known. Place a quick call to Roku (the manufacturer of the new set-top box) and Netflix and let them know how you feel.
Call: 888-600-7658 (Roku)
Call: 888-638-3549 (Netflix)
In both cases, you will probably want to have your customer number (found at the bottom of the page) ready. If you are not a customer, you could call and say you WOULD be one if only they offered captions on streaming video.
Netflix Isn’t Alone
Netflix is the not the only company or product ignoring this important feature. Look at your your XBox 360, PlayStation 3, iPhone, and AppleTV to see if captions are supported for all the video offered. You’ll most likely find it isn’t widely supported.
In addition to streaming video over the internet, basic HD Video is posing another barrier to accessing closed captions: HDMI & Component Video connections won’t transmit closed caption data, so your television can’t convert the signal (it has to be done by the Blu-Ray Player or HD Cable Box — many of which do not have this feature).
It’s amazing that purchasing the newest technology — that new HD TV or PlayStation 3 — takes us back to the dark ages of captioning. It’s really sad: this is the digital age.
Call and e-mail to make our opinions be heard! Let’s speak up and make a difference.
Damon Timm
Rosa Lee
More information about the set-top box is at:
http://www.roku.com/netflixplayer/
http://www.netflix.com
Information about the lack of CC on HD connections:
http://www.alldeaf.com/captioning-sign-language-interpreter/39116-hdmi-component-hdtv-not-support-captioning.html
http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/showthread.php?t=699933
Info about the PS3’s lack of CC support:
http://boardsus.playstation.com/playstation/board/message?board.id=ps3&thread.id=1929162
Contact the FCC with a complain at: fccinfo@fcc.gov or fax: 866-418-0232
by Ben Vess on 05.20.2008 @ 6:57 pm [link]
I think AppleTV does have CC feature. I have a macbook and it does have cc feature for my dvd movies.
Yep, CC. Not subtitles.
Ben
by stevie on 05.20.2008 @ 7:28 pm [link]
fyi - i have a blue ray player and a HD TV and the blue ray won’t transmit captions either!
i’ve been using subtitles without any trouble up till a few days ago when I rented “mad money” - no subtitles. gasp - can’t watch the show.
by Bill on 05.21.2008 @ 7:22 am [link]
See also CaptionsON
http://captionson.com/viewer.asp
by Sam © Copyright from Texas on 05.21.2008 @ 11:12 pm [link]
Ben vess, there is no CC on AppleTV. Not yet.
Rosa, there is CC available on iPhone already. As I demo on iPhone with OFFICIAL movies that been download from iTunes.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wpcjQaMRFw0
by So long, Netflix « arbofo on 05.22.2008 @ 3:16 pm [link]
[...] To compensate for the numerous errors in their movie listings for captions/subtitles*, I was cross-referencing their records with what I found in library catalogs and Amazon. I was incensed when I found that Netflix’s copies of Sherrybaby and Born into Brothels were not captioned- the copies I borrowed from my public library had been purchased from another distributor and did have captions. And when I wrote to make a suggestion to Netflix about making their caption/subtitle data more accessible, I was met with a rude response from a customer service representative. However, the straw that broke the camel’s back arrived when news broke about Netflix’s partnership with Roku to provide On-Demand movies. It’s an interesting innovation; too bad it doesn’t support captioning. [...]
by Chris on 09.3.2008 @ 8:43 am [link]
I have recieve roku box and it workes nice but no CC. I wonder if that voliates ADA laws ?