DianrezMusings on communication
About this Entry
Posted by: dianrez

Visit dianrez's Xanga Site

Original: 9/3/2007 1:37 AM
Views: 180
Comments: 7
eProps: 2

Read Comments
Post a Comment
Back to Your Xanga Site


Who gave the eProps?
2 eProps!2 eProps! 2 eProps from:
drmzz


Monday, September 03, 2007

Tony Coelho, Original Author of the ADA

 

On a recent PBS show, former Congressman Tony Coelho was a panelist interviewed about his own disability: epilepsy, and the fact that he authored the original ADA passed seventeen years ago.

His description of his epilepsy as a "condition of the human nature" no different than other variations such as deafness caught my attention immediately. Also what caught my attention was that the panel moderator cut him off whenever he tried to explain why it shouldn't be treated as a medical condition.

He described being denied opportunities because of the epilepsy. He was denied training for the priesthood because Catholic canon law at the time forbade epileptics, among other groups, from being ordained. He was not allowed to enlist for service in the Vietnam War. He was deprived of his driver's license and his medical insurance once word got out that he had epilepsy, thought to be from a traffic accident when he was 15.

"Seizures are just something that happens." Tony said. "It is part of my life and doesn't bother me most of the time." But he had a bone to pick with the doctors who wanted to medicate him and get rid of the seizures. "The drugs sedated me, gave me bothersome side effects, and disrupted my life." He went on to remark that people were afraid of the possibility of his having seizures and could not understand why he was opposed to the drugs. "Life goes on. We all have to accept our shortcomings." The moderator immediately went to another panelist.

What makes it difficult for us as a community, defined by our non-hearing lifestyle, is the same thing that makes it difficult for Tony Coelho. Everybody else, starting with the medical profession, expects us to go and get "fixed" no matter what the cost. Tony is telling us that we have the right to define for ourselves what is normalcy and what we are capable of accomplishing. The ADA act is just the opening for us to do just that, to be allowed to be accepted as we are and to define our own capabilities rather than allow others to define them for us.

 Posted 9/3/2007 1:37 AM - 180 views - 7 comments

Give eProps or Post a Comment

7 Comments

Just amazing about how the moderator cut him off!

I remember there was a panel discusson about Sound and Fury years ago in NYC. Only 3 people on the panel were deaf. They were pretty much balanced and fair, unlike the others on the panel. I had a question or two to ask the other panelists. Most in the audience were hearing. God knows how many times I have raised my hand only to be ignored by the moderator on purpose, even when there was hardly anyone wanting to ask a question at the time. I got fed up and stood up every time she picks who can talk instead of just raising my hand to no avail. Thanks to this interpreter who noticed that I have been constantly ignored and forced the attention on the moderator to let me participate. I finally did and the moderator doesn't look too happy.

I can't seem to remember what I said and the question I asked, but I do remember their silence except for the deaf panelist who commented briefly. The moderator seems to be in hurry to get rid of me. After the panel, I was approached by these two deaf professionals, thanking me for bringing it up for the audience to hear.

Katherine
Posted 9/3/2007 8:52 AM by Katherine - reply

Visit drmzz's Xanga Site!

Humans are a funny bunch. Like Tony, we have a perspective in life that not many people experience. People often think they need to intervene. There was a blind guy who visited my class several semesters ago and he was a radical person. He refused others' assistance to help him cross the street or use a cane. He defines his reality and not via from others. Katherine, you go girl!

Posted 9/3/2007 12:22 PM by drmzz - reply

When I said 2 deaf professionals, I meant to say deaf panelists!
Posted 9/3/2007 3:08 PM by Katherine - reply

Visit Jeanboutcher's Xanga Site!

Was "deafness" suggested to add in the ADA by Senator Tom Harkins who had a deaf brother? Harkins himself was a supporter of of the DPN. I believe I had seen Harkins there where  George W. H. Bush signed ADA in 1990. 

Jean

Posted 9/3/2007 4:54 PM by Jeanboutcher - reply

Does anyone know if this program made it online?

(epileptic here)
Posted 9/4/2007 6:39 AM by mcg - reply

Visit dianrez's Xanga Site!

McG: I believe this is the episode that I was watching: http://www.pbs.org/secondopinion/episodes/epilepsy/panelists/

Jean: There were many who worked on the ADA, and deafness was always included from the start. The panelist program mentioned once, without elaborating, that the ADA did not directly assist Tony Coelho because the definition did not include some aspects of epilepsy.

Posted 9/4/2007 10:15 AM by dianrez - reply

Hi, dianrez, To Katherine, That is an interesting view on this situation. Looks like the host's mind set up about us the deafies, that we are separated from people?? I just wrote an article all about this. I guess I am still fresh in the mind all about this. We need to re-educate those hearing people what we are! deafk
Posted 9/4/2007 7:23 PM by b-deaf (site) - reply


Choose Identity
(?)
 
Give eProps (?)
Post a Comment
Add Link | Preview HTML comment help 
Profile Pic:
Default  |  Choose »  (?)



Back to dianrez's Xanga Site!
Note: your comment will appear in dianrez's local time zone:
GMT -05:00 (Eastern Standard - US, Canada)
Free Web Counters
Free Counter